Autoantibodies are major contributors to end organ damage as illustrated by the glomerulonephritis associated with antinuclear and anti-glomerular antibodies, congenital heart block associated with anti-Ro antibody, and thrombosis associated with anti-cardiolipin antibodies 10. However, B cells can contribute to SLE pathogenesis through additional pathways. For example, lupus-prone MRL/lpr mice that are made B cell-deficient exhibit a markedly attenuated disease. These mice have an absence of autoantibodies, as expected, but also display a dramatic lack in T-cell activation. This study, by Shlomchik and colleagues 11, implied an essential role for B cells, but not necessarily autoantibodies, in the pathogenesis of lupus 11. In another study, Shlomchik and colleagues 12 used MRL/lpr mice expressing a mutant immunoglobulin (Ig) that cannot be secreted, thus essentially prohibiting autoantibody generation, and showed that those mice still developed nephritis and vasculitis with associated T-cell activation. That study convincingly showed that B cells may contribute to the development of lupus in ways that are independent of autoantibodies. The additional role of B cells as antigen-presenting cells that mediate T-cell activation in lupus comes from MRL/lpr mice studies showing that B-cell deficiency leads to reduced CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ T-cell activation 13.

Besides secreting proinflammatory cytokines like interleukin-6 (IL-6) and interferon-gamma (IFN-γ), B cells may secrete IL-10, which has an anti-inflammatory function. Therefore, B cells that secrete IL-10 (or B10 cells) have been called regulatory B cells and were first reported in B10.PL mice in which IL-10-producing B cells were found to regulate the severity of experimental auto-immune encephalitis 14. In murine lupus, IL-10 deficiency was found to contribute to more severe disease with an increase in Th1 cytokine levels 15. A recent study using CD19^-/- NZB/W mice reported that B10 cells could induce expansion of regulatory T cells, a subset of T cells with immunosuppressive function 16. However, data from human lupus reveal a different facet of IL-10. In the case of human SLE, studies suggest that IL-10 promotes rather than inhibits lupus 17. A better understanding of the role of IL-10-producing B cells and the mechanism of action of IL-10 is required to explain the differences between the murine and human data.

Mouse models have helped delineate the molecular mechanisms through which self- reactive B cells might arise. Sle1 is a lupus susceptibility locus derived from the NZM2410 mouse strain. Using Sle1 congenic C57Bl6 mice, Kumar and colleagues 18 reported that the auto-immune-associated variant of the Ly108 gene, a member of the SLAM family of immune cell receptors which lies within the Sle1 locus, leads to loss of B-cell tolerance because of impaired negative selection of autoreactive B cells at the immature B-cell stage. On the other hand, increased B-cell signaling, especially in the case of mature peripheral B cells, has been implicated in the pathogenesis of humoral autoimmunity. Mice that are deficient in various inhibitory molecules that dampen B-cell receptor (BCR) signaling, such as SHP-1 19, Lyn 20, or FcγRIIb 21, develop systemic autoimmunity. Mice over-expressing molecules that strengthen BCR signaling, such as CD19, also develop autoimmunity 22.

Recent studies have implicated a class of immune system receptors called Toll-like receptors (TLRs) in the synergistic activation of B cells by BCR and TLR signaling. Simultaneous engagement of BCRs that are specific for DNA by nuclear antigens that are abundant in apoptotic material and TLR9 on B cells causes activation of both BCR and TLR signaling pathways 23. In the NZB/W and MRL/lpr mouse models of lupus, activation of TLR9 with a synthetic DNA ligand causes accelerated nephritis with increased anti-DNA antibody levels 24. On the other hand, TLR9-deficient autoimmune mouse models exhibit lower levels of anti-double-stranded DNA (anti-dsDNA) and anti-chromatin antibody 25. Similarly, B cells possessing BCRs specific for RNA could be synergistically activated by BCR and TLR7 signaling 26. These findings were supported by research in the BXSB mouse model of lupus. Duplication of the TLR7 gene in the Yaa lupus susceptibility locus leads to increased gene dosage effects that contribute to the lupus-like phenotype seen in this model 27.

Defects that may lead to increased survival of autoreactive B cells have also been found to contribute to the development of autoimmunity. B-cell activation factor (BAFF) is a major B-cell survival factor that functions particularly at the transitional B-cell stage. BAFF transgenic mice develop a lupus-like disease with expansion of the peripheral B-cell pool and heightened production of autoantibodies 28. Increased BAFF levels are thought to infringe the negative selection checkpoint at the T1 transitional stage, thereby allowing the survival and maturation of autoreactive B cells in the periphery and their participation in the germinal center reaction. These findings are supported by the observations that lupus-prone mice exhibit elevated serum BAFF levels and that administration of TACI-Ig, which acts as a soluble receptor for BAFF, is effective in treating murine lupus 29.

The obligatory role of T cells in lupus pathogenesis has been demonstrated by using several genetically engineered mouse models 30. Lupus T cells are likely to contribute to disease through contact-dependent mechanisms (mediated by CD40L:CD40, OX40L:OX40, and so on) as well as released cytokines 30. One important cytokine secreted by the Th1 cells is IFN-γ, which plays a pivotal role in the production of pathogenic isotypes of antinuclear autoantibodies in murine lupus models. Expression of IFN-γ in the skin of transgenic mice leads to the production of anti-DNA and anti-Sm auto-antibodies 31. A deficiency of IFN-γ in MRL/lpr and NZB/W lupus-prone mice leads to reduced anti-DNA antibody levels 3233. In support of these findings, blocking the IFN-γ receptor with monoclonal antibodies or soluble IFN-γ receptor reduces disease activity in lupus-prone mice 3435.

CD4⁺ T h17 cells are a recently described CD4⁺ T-cell subset that appears to mediate pathogenesis in some lupus mouse models 36. However, it has become clear that the contribution of Th17 cells to autoimmunity is far more complex, depending on the disease and mouse model 37. Studies in patients with SLE or related diseases have demonstrated that Th17 cells may have a role in disease development in some, but not all, patients 38. Given the heterogeneity of the disease, it may be possible that Th17 cells play a role in lupus pathogenesis in a genetically defined subset of subjects or in particular end organ manifestations and that anti-IL -17 therapy may be helpful specifically in those patients. In addition, the regulatory T cell subset appears to modulate the breakdown of T-cell tolerance in lupus 39. Clearly, we need to gain a better understanding of how pathogenic T cells (Th17 cells) and regulatory T cells, perhaps in yinyang fashion, dictate disease activity in lupus.

Monocytes/macrophages from patients with lupus have been found to have a reduced capacity to phagocytose apoptotic materials 40, and their numbers were reduced in the inflammatory exudates from patients with SLE 41. It was postulated, on the basis of those studies, that the defective phagocytosis of monocytes/macrophages contributed to inefficient clearing of apoptotic materials, leading to autoimmunity 42, a notion that is supported by mice lacking the myeloid cell receptors, Tyro3, Axl, and Mer receptor tyrosine kinases 4344. Whereas c-mer knockout mice exhibited increased anti-dsDNA autoantibody levels without any significant renal pathology 43, Tyro3/Axl/Mer triple-knockout mice exhibited high levels of autoantibodies along with multiple end organ involvement 44.

Monocytes/macrophages can contribute to disease in another important way: through the elaboration of proinflammatory cytokines and chemokines. This is illustrated by macrophages from B6.Sle3 congenic mice, in which Sle3 is a lupus susceptibility locus derived from the NZM2410 lupus-prone strain 45. These murine studies showed that monocytes/macrophages in lupus probably have defects beyond abnormal phagocytosis and that these cells may take part in aberrant regulation of the immune system. A study by Kilmon and colleagues 46 demonstrated that macrophages regulate B-cell tolerance by secreting regulatory factors like IL-6 and CD40L and that macrophages from lupus-prone MRL/lpr mice are less capable of repressing Ig secretion coincident with reduced secretion of these repressive factors. Collectively, these findings implicate a more significant role for monocytes/macrophages in the pathogenesis of lupus, but further studies in patients with SLE are necessary to substantiate these findings.

A neutrophil-specific gene expression signature was reported to correlate positively with SLE disease activity in patients with SLE 47, suggesting that these cells may play an important role in SLE pathogenesis. The exact mechanism by which this occurs is not yet clear. However, a recent study demonstrated that neutrophil extracellular traps, which are networks of DNA, histones, and neutrophil proteins that function primarily to trap microorganisms, may be involved in SLE pathogenesis, possibly by generating autoantigens and serving as adjuvants 48. The role of neutrophils in murine lupus, unlike that in human lupus, is poorly studied.

Studies in mouse models have been pivotal in determining the role that dendritic cells (DCs) play in the pathogenesis of lupus. One of the earliest findings implicating the putative role of DCs in the breakdown of tolerance was that transferring DCs from normal donor mice to normal recipient mice could cause loss of tolerance in the host, leading to the appearance of anti-DNA and anticardiolipin autoantibodies 49. A study by Chen and colleagues 50 showed that mice with defective DC apoptosis accumulated large numbers of DCs and exhibited chronic lymphocyte activation and systemic autoimmunity.

Other studies using murine models have helped in identifying the genetic loci responsible for imparting the abnormal phenotypes seen in DCs from lupus-prone mice. One such locus is Sle3, which is a lupus susceptibility locus derived from the NZM2410 strain of lupus-prone mice. C57BL/6 (B6) mice congenic for Sle3 develop moderate glomerulonephritis along with modest levels of antinuclear antibodies 51. Moreover, the DCs from B6.Sle3 congenics are less susceptible to apoptosis, have a more mature phenotype, and are more proinflammatory. They are also more efficient in stimulating T cells in vitro and eliciting autoantibodies in vivo compared with DCs from normal B6 mice 45. These studies provided insights into genetic factors and immune mechanisms related to abnormal DC activation in murine lupus.

Studies have also shown that DCs play an important role in SLE pathogenesis by secreting potent proinflammatory cytokines, such as type I IFNs (IFN-α) 52. Immune complexes (ICs) purified from sera of patients with SLE were found to stimulate plasmacytoid DCs (pDCs) to produce IFN-α 53. Later studies revealed a possible role of TLRs as potent inducers of IFN-α production by activated pDCs in lupus. IFN-α secreted by activated pDCs was found to directly influence B cells to produce antibodies of the IgG subclass against soluble autoantigens in mice 54. This cytokine also upregulated BAFF expression by monocytes and mature DCs, which promotes both the survival of autoreactive B cells and their differentiation into plasmablasts 55. Together, these reciprocal events lead to a pathogenic cycle, in which both the innate and adaptive immune systems cooperate and feedback upon each other, eventually leading to high titers of autoantibodies.

Anti-DNA and DNA ICs were the first ICs isolated from kidney elutes of patients with SLE and mouse models 56. Intraperitoneal injection of human and murine anti-DNA antibodies was found to trigger lupuslike kidney disease 57, establishing a direct role of these antibodies in the pathogenesis of lupus nephritis. Similarly, transgenic overexpression of Ig anti-DNA antibodies in mouse models can lead to renal pathology similar to that seen in human lupus nephritis, highlighting a causal role for autoantibodies in the development of lupus nephritis 58.

Various mechanisms have been proposed to explain how anti-DNA antibodies may lead to renal disease in lupus 59. Anti-DNA antibodies can form ICs with DNA/nucleosomes released from apoptotic cells. Eventually, ICs become deposited in the kidney, leading to the initiation of a local inflammatory response through FcγR-or complement-mediated mechanisms or both. Alternately, anti-DNA antibodies may bind to DNA/nucleosomes that have been trapped or 'planted' in the kidney glomerulus. A third mechanism suggests possible cross-reactivity between anti-DNA antibodies and local renal antigens like laminin, alpha-actinin, and heparan sulfate 60.

Other studies have shown that anti-DNA antibodies are not an absolute requirement for development of SLE. NZM2328.Lc4 mice exhibit lupus-like disease with glomerular IC deposits and eventually develop fatal lupus nephritis. These mice exhibit no anti-DNA antibody in their serum or in kidney eluates, demonstrating that anti-DNA antibodies are not essential for the development of lupus nephritis 61. Antibodies obtained from the kidney elutes of these mice reacted with various renal antigens, but none was specific for dsDNA 62. Another study eluted Igs from renal tissues obtained from patients with lupus at autopsy and screened the Igs against a panel of 14 different antigens, which included dsDNA, chromatin, Sm, SSA, SSB, and histones 63. These authors found that only 0.3% to 41.3% of total kidney-eluted IgG reacted with these antigens. Therefore, a vast majority of renal antibodies bind to yet-unknown antigens. In support of this idea, a study using a glomerular proteome array showed that serum from lupus mice and patients reacts with multiple nuclear and matrix-derived autoantigens 64.

Lymphoid aggregates with T cells and B cells have been observed within the kidneys afflicted by lupus nephritis, although their intrarenal roles remain to be fully appreciated. T cells also play a major role in pathogenesis of SLE. Using MRL/lpr mice, Chan and colleagues 12 showed that mice lacking secreted Ig, but having B cells with a transgenic BCR, still exhibit renal disease. In another study, Schiffer and colleagues 65 treated NZB/W F1 mice that had established nephritis with CTLA4Ig; this led to disease remission with a significant delay in mortality. Using a transgenic mouse model system, Heymann and colleagues 66 demonstrated that both cytotoxic T (Tc) cells and Th cells have direct roles in glomerulonephritis. The authors used transgenic mice expressing the model antigens ovalbumin and hen egg lysozyme in glomerular epithelial cells called podocytes. Co-injection of ovalbumin-specific transgenic CD8⁺ Tc and CD4⁺ Th cells into these mice resulted in periglomerular mononuclear infiltrates and inflammation of parietal epithelial cells, similar to lesions frequently observed in human chronic glomerulonephritis. The ovalbumin-specific CD8⁺ Tc cells were found to be activated and expanded in the renal lymph nodes, and the activation of T cells in turn could be prevented by depletion of DCs. Crosstalk between tubulointerstitial DCs and Th cells resulted in intrarenal cytokine and chemokine production and in recruitment of more Tc cells, monocyte-derived DCs, and macrophages. That study was the first direct evidence that glomerular antigen-specific Tc and Th cells can induce glomerulonephritis in a process regulated by DCs. Although similar studies in the context of lupus nephritis are eagerly awaited, the above studies suggest that type IV hypersensitivity-driven mechanisms are likely to be important in mediating autoimmune nephritis.

Kidneys of nephritic NZM2328 mice show high levels of expression of Th1-type cytokines like IFN-γ and IL-12 67. Administration of IFN-γ, a Th1 cytokine, to NZB/W F1 mice exacerbates disease, whereas the deficiency of IFN-γ in MRL/lpr mice ameliorates nephritis 3234. Similarly, inhibition of IL-18, a cytokine that induces IFN-γ and other Th1 cytokines, was found to cause a significant reduction in lymphoproliferation and IFN-γ production and resulted in a decrease in lupus nephritis 68. These studies reinforce the concept that type IV hypersensitivity reactions may also contribute to lupus nephritis.

Other studies have shown a possible role for IL-4, a Th2-type cytokine, in glomerulosclerosis in which transgenic overexpression of IL-4 was found to facilitate glomerulosclerosis 69. In various studies, IL-4 was found to have a direct effect on fibroblast proliferation, collagen gene expression, and collagen synthesis 70. Moreover, inhibition of IL-4 signaling in various lupus-prone mouse models was found to protect mice from developing advanced nephritis in the presence of anti-DNA antibody and infiltrating inflammatory cells 32. Therefore, IL-4 appears to play a pivotal role in the pathogenesis of glomerulosclerosis and chronic renal fibrosis in lupus by acting directly upon resident renal cells.

Infiltration of DCs in the glomeruli and tubulointerstitial spaces of the kidneys has been reported in various murine models of nephritis, including NZB/W F1 67, anti-glomerular basement membrane (anti-GBM) 71, and mice engineered to express a foreign antigen on podocytes 66. DCs may promote lupus nephritis by several mechanisms. One mechanism may be through migration of DCs to local lymph nodes and presentation of renal antigens to autoreactive lymphocytes in the local lymph nodes, thereby initiating an autoimmune response against renal autoantigens 72. DCs may also secrete a variety of different proinflammatory and profibrotic cytokines like IL-6, IL-1, IL-18, IFN-α, tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-α), and transforming growth factor-beta to promote renal inflammation and fibrosis 73. Despite these possibilities, we do not currently understand the degree to which intrarenal DCs are important for lupus pathogenesis or the exact mechanisms through which they operate.

Similar to DCs, macrophages are recruited to the nephritic kidneys of patients with SLE and lupus-prone mice 7475 and influence the progression of lupus nephritis. In a study using poly(I:C)-induced lupus nephritis in NZB/W mice, proliferative glomerulonephritis was found to be associated with renalinfiltrating macrophages and renal expression of IFN-inducible genes, matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs), and growth factors 76. Glomerular crescent formation and renal MMP and growth factor expression were dependent on renal macrophages that expressed IL-10, MMPs, osteopontin, and various growth factors, including platelet-derived growth factor-C (PDGF-C) and heparin-binding epidermal growth factor-like growth factor (HB-EGF) 76. These findings accord a potentially important role for macrophages as mediators of aggressive nephritis in lupus by driving the expression of various cytokines and growth factors in the kidney. Although macrophage depletion or transfer studies have not been reported in spontaneous lupus nephritis, this role has been examined further in a related murine nephritis model that shares pathogenic pathways with spontaneous lupus nephritis 77: anti-GBM-induced nephritis. In the latter model, depletion and adoptive transfer studies have demonstrated a critical role for macrophages in the pathogenesis of nephritis 7879.

By implanting renal tubular epithelial cells genetically modified to produce colony-stimulating factor-1 (CSF-1) under the renal capsule of MRL/lpr mice, Kelley and colleagues 80 showed that CSF-1 and TNF-α released by tubular epithelial cells were responsible for promoting renal pathology by fostering macrophage accumulation. In a study using NZB/W lupus-prone mice, Schiffer and colleagues 75 identified an activated type II macrophage population as a key marker for proteinuria onset and disease remission and suggested that therapy for lupus nephritis include strategies that prevent both activation of monocytes and their migration to the kidney.

Neutrophils, another myeloid cell subtype, have also been shown to infiltrate nephritic kidneys and contribute to the pathogenesis of experimental nephritis 81, although their role in lupus nephritis is less well defined. Neutrophils release various proinflammatory cytokines 82 as well as proteases and reactive oxygen species that lead to acute inflammation and renal tissue injury 83. Further studies in murine models are clearly warranted.

It is clear that many intrinsic renal cells, including podocytes and tubular epithelial cells, have the capacity to costimulate intrarenal T cells via ICAM-I, MHC-II, B-7, and/or CD40-mediated mechanisms 848586 or by releasing pathogenic cytokines 87. However, the extent to which these intrarenal costimulatory mechanisms and cytokines are operative in spontaneous lupus nephritis remains unknown. On the other hand, the notion that intrinsic renal cells could be essential in mediating antibody-mediated nephritis is supported by bone marrow transfer or kidney transplant studies in mice challenged with anti-GBM sera 888990. These studies have defined the roles of MHC-II, INF-α, and Fn14 expression on intrinsic renal cells in mediating nephritis. Overall, we have a very limited understanding of the role that intrinsic renal cells play in spontaneous lupus nephritis.