Table 2 |
||||
|
Recommended therapies or modalities considered in four comprehensive treatment guidelines for lower-limb osteoarthritis published within the past 5 yearsa |
||||
| Guideline [reference] |
||||
|
|
||||
| ADMMC OA [14,15,16] |
EULAR [6] (Strength of |
|||
| Therapy/modality |
(Grade of evidenceb) |
ICSI [17,18] |
recommendationc) |
ACR [4,5] |
|
|
||||
| Acetaminophen |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
| (mild to moderate OA) |
||||
| NSAIDs |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
| (moderate to severe OA) |
||||
| Cox-2-specific NSAIDs |
Not discussed |
Recommended |
Not discussed |
Recommended |
| (2nd-line therapy) |
(2nd-line therapy in patient |
|||
| with high gastrointestinal risk) |
||||
| Corticosteroid joint injection |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
| Hyaluronic acid joint injection |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
Recommended (B) |
Recommended |
| Capsaicin cream |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
| Other topical cream |
Not discussed |
Recommended |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
| (e.g. NSAID cream) |
||||
| Opioid analgesics |
Recommended (B) |
Recommended |
Recommended (B) |
Recommended |
| Aerobic exercise |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
| Strengthening and |
Recommended (B) |
Recommended |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
| range-of-motion exercise |
||||
| Education |
Recommended (no grade) |
Recommended |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
| Arthritis self-management |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
| education |
||||
| Physical therapy |
Recommended (no grade) |
Recommended |
Recommended |
Recommended |
| Occupational therapy |
Recommended (C) |
Recommended |
Recommended |
Recommended |
| Telephone contact |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
Recommended (B) |
Recommended |
| Weight loss |
Recommended (B) |
Recommended |
Recommended (B) |
Recommended |
| Walking assistive devices |
Recommended (C) |
Recommended |
Recommended (B) |
Recommended |
| (e.g. shoe inserts, cane) |
||||
| Assistive devices for |
Recommended (C) |
Recommended |
Not discussed |
Recommended |
| activities of daily living |
||||
| Glucosamine (with or |
Not discussed |
Recommended |
Recommended (A) |
Not recommended |
| without chondroitin) |
||||
| Knee brace or taping |
Not discussed |
Not discussed |
Recommended (B) |
Recommended |
| Hot pack or ice pack |
Recommended (no grade) |
Recommended |
Not discussed |
Recommended |
| Joint protection techniques |
Recommended (no grade) |
Recommended |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
| Planning activities |
Recommended (no grade) |
Recommended |
Recommended (A) |
Recommended |
| Acupuncture |
Not discussed |
Recommended |
Not discussed |
Not recommended |
| Electrical stimulation (e.g. TENS) |
Not discussed |
Recommended |
Not discussed |
Not discussed |
| Massage |
Not discussed |
Recommended |
Not discussed |
Not discussed |
|
|
||||
|
aThis table covers only the four comprehensive treatment guidelines. For summary of recommendations of NSAID-specific guidelines, see Results section. bGrade of evidence: A = at least one high-quality randomized controlled trial with adequate power; B = evidence from underpowered randomized controlled; prospective controlled or historical controlled studies; C = consensus/expert opinion/uncontrolled trials; no grade = the therapy/modality was discussed in the text of the guideline, no level of evidence was provided to support the therapy/modality. cStrength of recommendation: A = directly based on category-1 evidence (meta-analysis of one or more randomized, controlled trials; B = directly based on category-2 evidence (at least one controlled study without randomization or at least one quasi-experimental study) or extrapolated recommendations from category-1 evidence; C = directly based on category-3 evidence (descriptive studies, such as comparative studies, correlation studies, or case-control studies) or extrapolated recommendations from category-1 or -2 evidence; D = directly based on category-4 evidence (expert committee reports or opinions and/or clinical experience of respected authorities) or extrapolated recommendations from category-2 or -3 evidence. ACR = American College of Rheumatology; ADMMC = Algorithms for the Diagnosis and Management of Musculoskeletal Complaints; COX-2 = cyclooxygenase-2; EULAR = European League Against Rheumatism; ICSI = Institute for Clinical Systems Improvement; NSAID = nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug; OA = osteoarthritis; TENS = transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation. |
||||
|
Pencharz et al. Arthritis Res 2002 4:36 doi:10.1186/ar381 |
||||