Table 2

Recommended therapies or modalities considered in four comprehensive treatment guidelines for lower-limb osteoarthritis published within the past 5 yearsa


Guideline [reference]



ADMMC OA [14,15,16]

EULAR [6] (Strength of

Therapy/modality
(Grade of evidenceb)
ICSI [17,18]
recommendationc)
ACR [4,5]

Acetaminophen
Recommended (A)
Recommended
Recommended (A)
Recommended




(mild to moderate OA)
NSAIDs
Recommended (A)
Recommended
Recommended (A)
Recommended




(moderate to severe OA)
Cox-2-specific NSAIDs
Not discussed
Recommended
Not discussed
Recommended


(2nd-line therapy)

(2nd-line therapy in patient




with high gastrointestinal risk)
Corticosteroid joint injection
Recommended (A)
Recommended
Recommended (A)
Recommended
Hyaluronic acid joint injection
Recommended (A)
Recommended
Recommended (B)
Recommended
Capsaicin cream
Recommended (A)
Recommended
Recommended (A)
Recommended
Other topical cream
Not discussed
Recommended
Recommended (A)
Recommended
(e.g. NSAID cream)




Opioid analgesics
Recommended (B)
Recommended
Recommended (B)
Recommended
Aerobic exercise
Recommended (A)
Recommended
Recommended (A)
Recommended
Strengthening and
Recommended (B)
Recommended
Recommended (A)
Recommended
range-of-motion exercise




Education
Recommended (no grade)
Recommended
Recommended (A)
Recommended
Arthritis self-management
Recommended (A)
Recommended
Recommended (A)
Recommended
education




Physical therapy
Recommended (no grade)
Recommended
Recommended
Recommended
Occupational therapy
Recommended (C)
Recommended
Recommended
Recommended
Telephone contact
Recommended (A)
Recommended
Recommended (B)
Recommended
Weight loss
Recommended (B)
Recommended
Recommended (B)
Recommended
Walking assistive devices
Recommended (C)
Recommended
Recommended (B)
Recommended
(e.g. shoe inserts, cane)




Assistive devices for
Recommended (C)
Recommended
Not discussed
Recommended
activities of daily living




Glucosamine (with or
Not discussed
Recommended
Recommended (A)
Not recommended
without chondroitin)




Knee brace or taping
Not discussed
Not discussed
Recommended (B)
Recommended
Hot pack or ice pack
Recommended (no grade)
Recommended
Not discussed
Recommended
Joint protection techniques
Recommended (no grade)
Recommended
Recommended (A)
Recommended
Planning activities
Recommended (no grade)
Recommended
Recommended (A)
Recommended
Acupuncture
Not discussed
Recommended
Not discussed
Not recommended
Electrical stimulation (e.g. TENS)
Not discussed
Recommended
Not discussed
Not discussed
Massage
Not discussed
Recommended
Not discussed
Not discussed

aThis table covers only the four comprehensive treatment guidelines. For summary of recommendations of NSAID-specific guidelines, see Results section. bGrade of evidence: A = at least one high-quality randomized controlled trial with adequate power; B = evidence from underpowered randomized controlled; prospective controlled or historical controlled studies; C = consensus/expert opinion/uncontrolled trials; no grade = the therapy/modality was discussed in the text of the guideline, no level of evidence was provided to support the therapy/modality. cStrength of recommendation: A = directly based on category-1 evidence (meta-analysis of one or more randomized, controlled trials; B = directly based on category-2 evidence (at least one controlled study without randomization or at least one quasi-experimental study) or extrapolated recommendations from category-1 evidence; C = directly based on category-3 evidence (descriptive studies, such as comparative studies, correlation studies, or case-control studies) or extrapolated recommendations from category-1 or -2 evidence; D = directly based on category-4 evidence (expert committee reports or opinions and/or clinical experience of respected authorities) or extrapolated recommendations from category-2 or -3 evidence. ACR = American College of Rheumatology; ADMMC = Algorithms for the Diagnosis and Management of Musculoskeletal Complaints; COX-2 = cyclooxygenase-2; EULAR = European League Against Rheumatism; ICSI = Institute for Clinical Systems Improvement; NSAID = nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug; OA = osteoarthritis; TENS = transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation.

Pencharz et al. Arthritis Res 2002 4:36   doi:10.1186/ar381